| Place | Name | Affiliation | Time | 209m | 409m | 609m | 809m | 1009m | 1209m | 1409m | Mile
|
| 1 | Lawi Lalang | ARIZ | 3:54.74 | 30.16 (30.16) | 59.87 (29.72) | 1:29.88 (30.02) | 1:59.76 (29.88) | 2:29.35 (29.59) | 2:58.47 (29.13) | 3:27.25 (28.78) | 3:54.74 (27.49) |
| 2 | Ryan Hill | NCSU | 3:55.25 | 30.57 (30.57) | 1:00.76 (30.19) | 1:31.15 (30.39) | 2:01.69 (30.55) | 2:31.91 (30.22) | 3:01.09 (29.18) | 3:28.87 (27.79) | 3:55.25 (26.38) |
| 3 | Austin Mudd | WIS | 3:57.93 | 30.52 (30.52) | 1:00.37 (29.85) | 1:30.89 (30.53) | 2:01.78 (30.89) | 2:32.66 (30.88) | 3:02.37 (29.72) | 3:30.37 (28.00) | 3:57.93 (27.56) |
| 4 | Tyler Stutzman | STAN | 3:59.70 | 30.68 (30.68) | 1:00.52 (29.84) | 1:31.55 (31.04) | 2:02.06 (30.51) | 2:32.43 (30.37) | 3:01.98 (29.55) | 3:31.26 (29.29) | 3:59.70 (28.44) |
| 5 | John Simons | MINN | 3:59.71 | 30.72 (30.72) | 1:00.96 (30.25) | 1:31.40 (30.44) | 2:01.89 (30.49) | 2:32.24 (30.35) | 3:01.81 (29.58) | 3:30.95 (29.15) | 3:59.71 (28.77) |
| 6 | Christopher Fallon | OHST | 4:02.28 | 31.10 (31.10) | 1:01.13 (30.03) | 1:31.87 (30.75) | 2:02.73 (30.87) | 2:32.96 (30.23) | 3:03.54 (30.59) | 3:33.85 (30.31) | 4:02.28 (28.43) |
| 7 | Chris O'Hare | TULS | 4:02.96 | 30.35 (30.35) | 1:00.25 (29.90) | 1:31.35 (31.11) | 2:02.23 (30.88) | 2:31.63 (29.41) | 3:01.37 (29.74) | 3:32.39 (31.03) | 4:02.96 (30.57) |
| 8 | Michael Atchoo | STAN | 4:04.92 | 30.88 (30.88) | 1:00.72 (29.84) | 1:31.75 (31.04) | 2:02.36 (30.61) | 2:33.06 (30.70) | 3:03.42 (30.37) | 3:34.37 (30.95) | 4:04.92 (30.55) |
| 9 | Robby Creese | PSU | 4:08.82 | 30.75 (30.75) | 1:00.50 (29.75) | 1:30.42 (29.93) | 2:01.17 (30.75) | 2:32.53 (31.36) | 3:04.58 (32.06) | 3:36.39 (31.82) | 4:08.82 (32.43) |
| DNF | Raul Botezan | OKST | NT | 31.00 (31.00) | 1:01.18 (30.18) | 1:31.98 (30.81) | 2:04.05 (32.08) |