| Place | Athlete Name | | Affiliation | Time | Qual |
|---|
| 1 | Michael Rutt | | New Jersey New York TC | 1:50.44 | Q | | 2 | Owen Dawson | | unattached | 1:50.83 | | | 3 | Drake Sterling | | Indiana Invaders | 1:52.25 | | | 4 | James O'Brien | | Indiana Invaders | 1:53.63 | | | 5 | Peter Najem | | Boston AA | 1:54.37 | | |
|
| Place | Athlete Name | | Affiliation | Time | Qual |
|---|
| 1 | Tevan Everett | | New Jersey New York TC | 1:49.74 | Q | | 2 | Brian Hill | | Boston AA | 1:50.43 | | | 3 | Liam Boylan-Pett | | New Jersey New York TC | 1:50.49 | | | 4 | Karjuan Williams | | unattached | 1:50.94 | | | 5 | Josh Wilks | | Seton Hill | 1:51.38 | |
|